Revisiting the Selection of Stainless Steel in Water and Wastewater Treatment Environments: Part 3

June 26, 2002
Materials Selection

About the author: Frederick Bloetscher, Ph.D., P.E., is with Public Utility Management and Planning Services, Inc., Hollywood, Fla. Phone 954-925-3492; Fax 954-925-2692; e-mail [email protected] Richard J. Bullock is with Weir Materials and Foundries, Ponte Vedra Beach, Fla. Phone 904-285-8039; Fax 904-285-8043; e-mail [email protected]. Robert E. Fergen, P.E., is with Hazen and Sawyer, P.C., Raleigh, N.C. Phone 919-833-7152; Fax 919-833-1828; e-mail [email protected]. Gerhardt M. Witt, P.G., is with Gerhardt M. Witt & Associates, Inc., West Palm Beach, Fla. Phone 561-642-9923; Fax 561-642-3327; e-mail [email protected]. Gary D. Fries, P.E., is with Boyle Engineering Corporation, Orlando, Fla. Phone 407-425-1100; Fax 407-422-3866; e-mail [email protected].

undefined

Part 1 focused on the problems and microbiological concerns of using certain types of stainless steel in specific applications.

Part 2 explained microbial influences on stainless steel and described tests to be performed before the selection process.

Hollywood, Florida

Since the late 1960s, more than 1,600 treatment facilities have included stainless steel for aeration, digester gas and sludge piping.2 In RO plants, seawater is filtered and pumped at high pressure through cells containing the membrane that remove the contaminants.13 In desalination, the most corrosive fluid is aerated water. The most important corrosion mechanisms for stainless steel in crevice corrosion for parent metal and pitting is the weld.13 Seawater usually is chlorinated to prevent biofouling, but chlorine has downstream impacts on the membranes. The resistance to crevice corrosion in chlorinated seawater at temperatures between 4 and 30° C is important.

As part of a program of creating diversity in its options, the City of Hollywood, Fla., pursued the use of a brackish aquifer (i.e., Floridan aquifer is an artesian confined supply) to supplement its withdrawals from the Biscayne aquifer (a shallow water table aquifer). The intent was to have multiple sources of water available in the event of drought, restrictions or contamination. The City drilled a test/production well into the brackish Floridan Aquifer System. Investigative studies found that the well had TDS levels of 3,400 mg/L and chlorides of 2,200 mg/L, making the existing lime softening treatment impossible. However, the well had artesian pressure at the ground surface and sufficient quantities of water were available, meaning that the brackish water could be easily treated by low-pressure reverse osmosis.

The City’s operations staff and consultant determined that the piping for the brackish supply needed to be run above ground in the water plant due to subsurface congestion. As a result, the water plant staff and consultant deemed that Type 316L stainless steel would protect the pipe from the salts anticipated from the brackish water supply and that the material would be resistant to external corrosion so pipe maintenance would be minimized.

Type 316L stainless steel was selected over HDPE and ductile iron options for the raw water lines. While the chemical resistance of HDPE is similar to stainless steel and they have similar weights, the potential for degradation by sunlight was the reason it was rejected. Reduced maintenance (no need for painting), improved chemical and corrosion resistance and the ability to use thin walled, lightweight sections were the reasons stainless steel was chosen over ductile iron. Ductile iron requires larger and more numerous piers (support foundation) due to weight and short laying lengths that would take longer and cost more to erect than the stainless steel, and special linings would be needed to prevent iron related fouling (caused by iron bacteria and iron precipitation) from affecting the membrane treatment process.6 Bacterial analysis of the raw water revealed the presence of iron bacteria (Gallionella ferruginia and Sphaerotilus natans) and slime forming bacteria (Pseudomonas species and others).

Over 1,100 feet of 36?, 316L stainless steel, 3?8?-thick pipe was installed (see Figure 5). The thinner walled pipe was used due to cost considerations and the fact that the raw water pressure would be small. Soon after installation and hydro-testing of the 316L stainless steel plant and piping system, external corrosion began to occur in the form of rust stains, scratches and pinhole leaks (see Figure 6). Within a year of installation, more than 20 leaks developed in the pipe. The leaks occurred along the pipe section as well as near couplings and at the edges of the pipes. In addition, similar activity was noted on the City’s reverse osmosis skids. Most of the corrosion at the skids was present in the joints where exposure to stagnant 3,400 mg/L TDS water (2,200 mg/L of chlorides) occurred at the O-rings and in the J-bends. Investigation of the phenomena revealed that there were several causes of the leaks, all associated with corrosion cells caused by both anodic action and microbiological activity.

               The heat tint was not removed as specified or in conformance with standard practice in any of the circumferential field welds, inside or outside of the pipe. This resulted in sites for preferential anodic dissolution in the pipe that attracted both cathodic and microbiological corrosion (See Figure 6).

               Faint heat tint was detected in the internal, longitudinal welds. It had not been removed adequately.

               The complete draining of the pipeline after hydro-testing did not occur due to the failure to install drains by the contractor during construction, creating a long-term stagnant water condition. The result was that the high chloride content of the water and the naturally occurring and man-induced bacteria in the water were able to attack the pipe interior at the point where the oxygen content (interface) was significant (see Figure 7).

               The microbial activity was not considered a major issue when specifying the pipe, but extensive biofilm formation had occurred, especially at the edges of the pipes and crevices (see Figures 8–10).

Perhaps most importantly, the chlorides were too high for use of 316L stainless steel for the reverse osmosis portion of the plant. So, a more durable grade steel should have been specified based on current knowledge. The result is crevice corrosion in the J-bends (see Figures 11–13). Interestingly, this recommendation was made by steel manufacturers, which was surprising to the City and its engineer since the use of 316L stainless steel had been the industry standard for reverse osmosis systems in Florida up to that point.

The following actions were advised to correct the problem.

               Flare out all pits and pinholes and fill them with an epoxy paste material suitable for potable water service.

               Flush the piping, and do not store high chloride water for any period of time in the pipeline. Replacement with raw water that is potentially bacteria-laden is not the appropriate solution, nor is chlorine laden potable water.

               Remove all heat tint, both inside and outside of the pipe.

               Sterilize the pipe to reduce the microbial problem. Unfortunately, once the bacteria have attached to the pipe, they cannot be permanently removed, only controlled.

               When the pipe is replaced, use a more appropriate grade of stainless steel.

In addition to controlling the bacteria by replacing a number of wells (the groundwater was the source of the bacteria), the following tasks were implemented.

               Provide a routine disinfection program for water supply wells and raw water transmission pipes.

               Periodically sample and analyze wells and composite raw water for microbial growth.

               Use non-ferric materials (ABS, PVC and/or fiberglass) in the design of water supply wells and final casing strings, and use non-organic based drilling muds and proper disinfection procedures during drilling of wells.

               Use bronze (non-ferric and not red bronze) well pumps and motor housing for submersible motors. Fiberglass and/or PVC column pipe material is suitable for withstanding high concentrations of chlorine disinfection solutions such as calcium hypochlorite/sodium hypochlorite.

               Use non-ferric metals and plastics in piping appurtenances (valves, meters, nuts, bolts and screws).

The price for the repairs is $80,000, plus an annual upkeep cost. Lining of the pipe (a $200,000 option) also is being considered. The lining would bond to the existing pipe, thereby reducing the long-term potential for deterioration. Together, the repair amount is nearly half the cost of the initial installation of the above ground pipe.

Hindsight

If the City were to start over, a more appropriate material would have been selected. One such system that would have eliminated most of the problems would be the use of a higher grade, super-duplex stainless steel such as Zeron 100, 2205 or 2507. Corrosion resistance is the key at moderate temperatures. Corrosion rates are lower in second generation duplex and super duplex stainless steels than standard austenitic stainless steel as measured by critical pitting temperature and critical temperature for crevice corrosion. The critical pitting temperature is the temperature above which pitting corrosion will initiate and propagate to a visible extent within 24 hours. This tends to be higher with the super duplex stainless steel. The critical temperature for crevice corrosion CCT also tends to be higher for super-duplex stainless steels.4

Zeron 100 currently is being tested by the City in-situ as J-bends. Reviewing the current situation, Zeron 100 would have reduced corrosion damage because it is more resistant to pitting and crevice corrosion than other alloys or duplex stainless steels, particularly at higher temperatures.13 The higher chromium, molybdenum and nitrogen content provides good resistance to chloride-induced localized corrosion in aqueous environments and crevice corrosion. Most duplex stainless steels are far superior to Type 316L stainless steel.4

Conclusions

Stainless steel has been used where higher strength, high pressure and corrosion resistance are important. Older duplex stainless steel (typically 316L) has provided good performance in membrane plants. However, it has had limitations in the welded condition. This is due to the excessive ferrite that occurs in the weld metal, making corrosion more likely in brackish facilities where crevice corrosion becomes evident and, in some cases, where microbiological activity is present. Higher grade stainless steel should be considered in plants when the chlorides are higher than 1,000 mg/L, temperatures are high (greater than 15° C) or where substantial microbiological activity exists.

2205, 2507 and Zeron 100 are steel grades that have two additional benefits in reverse osmosis plants. The thickness of the castings for the high pressure pumps can be reduced as a result of higher strength of the steel, and thinner walled pipe for the feed water can be used as a result of its corrosion resistance. Smaller pipes are connected with Vitaulic rubber seals in a groove that can be rolled onto Zeron 100 10S piping.13

Welding, especially field welding, also creates considerable problems. Use of nitrogen alloying in duplex stainless steels such as the 2205, 2507 and Zeron 100 (a registered trade name of Weir Materials and Foundries) and the 6 Mo austenitics makes the heat zone corrosion resistance similar to that of the base metal, without the need to remove the tinting. The cost of higher-grade steel is greater, but the overall cost increase is small compared with the cost to repair 316L systems. Higher grade stainless steel should be considered when the chlorides are higher than 1000 mg/L, temperatures are high (greater than 15° C) or where substantial microbacteriological activity exists.

For many reverse osmosis applications, the use of higher grade stainless steel is more appropriate than the current standard of 316L stainless steel. As the City of Hollywood found out, this is especially true with regard to slow moving water and crevice corrosion (J-bends) where 316L appears to be an inappropriate choice. Higher grades of nitrogen alloyed duplex stainless steels have been used successfully in reverse osmosis and oil applications in the North Sea, Spain and the Spanish islands, the Philippines, Europe and the Middle East. However, these grades of steel have not seen much use in the United States.

Despite the initial cost of these higher grade stainless steels (perhaps 30 percent), their use does not increase costs prohibitively. Accurate life cycle cost development is important, but life cycle cost analyses indicate that for these conditions the higher grade stainless steels are more cost effective. Higher grades of stainless steel are manufactured at factories world-wide, so the availability and delivery should not differ significantly from that of 316L stainless steel. Biological resistance to standing water requires further scrutiny, but a recent NACE paper indicates good microbial resistance in the Zeron 100 applications.

Based on the City of Hollywood’s experience, the use of 316L stainless steel should be evaluated carefully due to the potential for problems in the erection and construction of water treatment facilities that will be in contact with high chloride water and/or other corrosive chemistries. As with many membrane facilities, much of the stainless steel is exposed (not buried), which subjected it to atmospheric as well as water quality problems. Therefore, unless the quality control of the raw and reject water (chemical, physical and microbial) can be assured, 316L stainless steel may not be the appropriate material for engineers to specify. Other steels are available and plastics may be more appropriate in situations where the pipe will not be exposed to sunlight (which adversely affects plastic pipe and certain coatings) or high pressures. For high pressure, high chloride applications, the use of higher-grade stainless steel is required.

For a list of references, go to our website at www.waterinfocenter.com.

Sponsored Recommendations

Get Utility Project Solutions

June 13, 2024
Lightweight, durable fiberglass conduit provides engineering benefits, performance and drives savings for successful utility project outcomes.

Meeting the Demands of Wastewater Treatment Plants

May 24, 2024
KAESER understands the important requirements wastewater treatment plant designers and operators consider when evaluating and selecting blowers and compressed air equipment. In...

Modernize OT Cybersecurity to Mitigate Risk

April 25, 2024
Rockwell Automation supports industry-leading Consumer Packaged Goods company, Church & Dwight, along their industrial cybersecurity journey.

2024 Manufacturing Trends Unpacking AI, Workforce, and Cybersecurity

April 25, 2024
The world of manufacturing is changing, and Generative AI is one of the many change agents. The 2024 State of Smart Manufacturing Report takes a deep dive into how Generative ...